Blog
Swell vs BigCommerce: Which Platform Fits Your Store in 2026?
A developer-focused Swell vs BigCommerce comparison for 2026: data model, variant limits, APIs, Catalyst, subscriptions, B2B and a worked cost example.

Swell and BigCommerce are both hosted commerce platforms with full APIs, and they charge nearly the same entry prices. The difference is where each one puts its effort. BigCommerce packages a lot of commerce as switchable features: multi-storefront, a B2B Edition, a large app catalog and a Next.js storefront called Catalyst. Swell gives developers a backend they reshape: custom models, custom fields on built-in models, subscriptions in the core order flow and a catalog without a published variant cap.
Short answer: pick BigCommerce if your requirements map onto features it already ships, especially multi-storefront, enterprise B2B and marketplace feeds. Pick Swell if your catalog, pricing or subscription logic does not fit a standard product model and you have developers who will own the build. On cost, the two diverge once sales pass BigCommerce's GMV caps or once you use a payment provider outside BigCommerce's embedded list.
This comparison is written for the developer or technical lead who will live with the decision. Every BigCommerce figure below was checked on BigCommerce's own site on November 2, 2026, and every Swell figure on Swell's pricing page and developer docs the same day. For a plan-by-plan breakdown of BigCommerce alone, see our BigCommerce pricing guide.
Key Takeaways
- BigCommerce wins on packaged breadth: native multi-storefront, B2B Edition with quotes and net terms, over 1,200 apps, marketplace and ad channels through its Channel Manager, and Catalyst, an MIT-licensed Next.js storefront.
- Swell wins on data-model freedom: you can create custom models, extend built-in ones and get created, updated and deleted events on each, while BigCommerce extends its fixed resources with custom fields and metafields.
- BigCommerce caps a product at 600 SKUs or variants (Platform Limits page, Nov 2026). Swell's pricing page lists unlimited variants on every plan.
- Subscriptions are a core Swell model with plans, trials and separate billing and fulfillment schedules. On BigCommerce they come from third-party apps.
- Cost diverges above BigCommerce's caps: in our worked example at $800K a year, BigCommerce Scale costs $6,468 in platform charges with an embedded provider and $10,788 with an open one, against $3,588 on Swell Standard. Processing fees come on top on both.
Two Hosted Platforms, Two Centers of Gravity
Both platforms host the backend, run the checkout and expose REST and GraphQL APIs. Neither is self-hosted. So the real question is not hosted versus self-managed, as it is with Swell vs WooCommerce, and not a closed storefront versus an open backend, as it is with Swell vs Shopify. It is closer to a choice between a feature catalog and a programmable backend.
BigCommerce's center of gravity is the control panel. Most capabilities are features you enable and configure per plan, and its APIs mirror those features closely. That is efficient when your business looks like the businesses BigCommerce designed for: a retailer or wholesaler with a conventional catalog, several brands or regions, and a need to list on marketplaces.
Swell's center of gravity is the data model. The admin dashboard and the APIs work on the same models, and you can add your own. That is efficient when the hard part of your store is something a standard product, order and customer model does not describe: configured products, subscription boxes, account-based pricing, or data that needs to drive checkout logic.
Data Model: Custom Models vs Metafields
BigCommerce
BigCommerce gives you two ways to attach extra data. Product custom fields are merchant-visible name and value pairs, capped at 200 per product with a 255-character value limit, according to BigCommerce's Platform Limits page (checked Nov 2, 2026). Metafields are the developer tool: key and value pairs with a namespace, attached to orders, products, categories, variants, brands and other resources. The create product metafield reference caps them at 250 per resource per client ID, and each has a permission set that controls whether other API accounts and the storefront can read or write it.
Metafields work well for decorating existing resources. They belong to the API account that created them, which matters if that API account or app is later deleted. What they do not give you is a new first-class resource with its own lifecycle. If you need a warranty registration, a gift registry or a quote record, you either store it in metafields on an existing resource or keep it in your own database.
Swell
Swell treats the schema as editable. Under Developer > Models in the dashboard you can create a new model, and you can set a model to extend a standard one such as products so its fields are inherited and merged, per the data models reference. Fields are typed (string, int, bool, date, array, object, link and others), and every model gets created, updated and deleted events by default, which feed webhooks. You can add custom event types with conditions.
Because custom data lives in typed fields on real models, you query and filter it through the same Backend API calls as built-in data. A warranty model linked to orders and accounts is a model, not a set of key-value pairs to parse.
Which shape fits
If you need a handful of extra attributes on products and orders, BigCommerce metafields are enough and well supported by its app ecosystem. If your business depends on records that do not exist in a standard commerce schema, Swell's model system saves you a second database and the sync work that comes with it.
Catalog Limits: 600 Variants vs Unlimited
BigCommerce's Platform Limits page lists a maximum of 600 SKUs or variants per product and 250 values per option (checked Nov 2, 2026). BigCommerce also offers modifiers, options that change price or capture input without creating a SKU, which is one way to stay under the variant cap when the extra choices do not need their own inventory.
Swell's pricing page lists unlimited product variants on all plans. Options can add to a product's price per value, can be shown conditionally based on a parent option, and can be marked as variant options so Swell generates combinations with their own price, images and inventory. Bundles are a product type made of other catalog products.
For most catalogs, 600 is plenty. It matters for made-to-order furniture, apparel with many size and color combinations, industrial parts with many dimensions, or any product where each combination must carry its own stock. If you are close to the cap today, test your largest product on both platforms before deciding.
APIs: What Each Platform Exposes
BigCommerce
BigCommerce has a broad, mature API surface: REST Management APIs, a GraphQL Admin API, the GraphQL Storefront API, a separate B2B REST Management API, Payments, Customer Login and provider APIs for shipping and tax. The GraphQL Storefront API covers catalog search and filtering, carts, checkout and signed-in customer data from one endpoint. It caps each request at a complexity score of 10,000 and a query depth of 16, and BigCommerce notes that storefront tokens created after June 30, 2026 do not support server-to-server calls, so server code should use private tokens.
Swell
Swell splits its API in two. The Backend API is REST with JSON, called from server code, and Swell's own dashboard and platform features run on it. The Frontend API, wrapped by the swell-js library, is authenticated with a public key and handles carts, customer accounts, subscriptions, payment methods and currency selection. Swell also offers a GraphQL frontend endpoint, but its docs describe it as an experimental alpha with no nested queries and no card tokenization, so plan headless builds around swell-js and REST.
Swell's Backend API quotas are part of the plan: 100K, 500K and 2M monthly API requests on Starter, Basic and Standard, unlimited on Unlimited, with $5 per extra 100K, per the pricing page. Factor that into any integration that polls heavily.
On API maturity, BigCommerce is ahead on GraphQL. On API reach, Swell's Backend API covers your custom models with the same query, filter and expand syntax as products and orders.
Headless: Catalyst vs Swell Themes and Custom Frontends
Catalyst is BigCommerce's headless storefront framework, built with Next.js, optimized for React Server Components and backed by the GraphQL Storefront API. Its GitHub repository is MIT licensed, and BigCommerce offers a one-click Catalyst app in its app marketplace. If your team already writes Next.js, Catalyst is a strong, maintained starting point, and it is one of the clearest places BigCommerce leads. BigCommerce's Omni-Channel Availability article also lists other storefront options, including WordPress, Drupal and Nuxt.js.
Swell has two paths. Hosted storefronts run on storefront apps with themes that merchants customize in the Swell Theme Editor, and Proxima is Swell's first official storefront app. The headless path is any frontend you build against swell-js and the Backend API. Swell does not ship a Next.js framework comparable to Catalyst, so a headless Swell build starts closer to a blank project.
The trade-off is reach versus control. Catalyst gives you more pre-built storefront, but its shape follows BigCommerce's resources. A Swell headless build takes more initial work and can expose your custom models directly in the frontend.
Subscriptions
Swell includes subscriptions on every plan. Per Swell's purchase options guide, any product can carry subscription plans, each with its own interval, price and optional trial. Physical subscriptions generate invoices on the billing schedule and orders on the fulfillment schedule, so billing and shipping can follow separate schedules. Subscriptions are API resources, so customer portals and custom renewal logic use the same Backend and Frontend APIs as the rest of the store.
BigCommerce does not ship native subscription billing. Subscriptions come from apps in its Recurring Billing and Subscriptions category, which lists options such as Ordergroove, Chargebee, PayWhirl and Rebillia (checked Nov 2, 2026). An app can be a fine choice for subscribe-and-save, but it adds a monthly fee and a second system that holds subscription state.
B2B and Wholesale
BigCommerce has the deeper packaged B2B offer. B2B Edition adds company account hierarchies with roles, quotes, purchase orders, net terms per account, company credit, a customizable buyer portal and buyer-specific price lists and catalogs. B2B Edition is not on the self-serve price list; its page leads to a demo request and enterprise pricing. On the pricing page, customer groups start on Growth and SKU-level Price Lists appear only on the Performance plan (checked Nov 2, 2026). The cost and timeline of a B2B Edition build sit closer to the BigCommerce enterprise pricing range than to the self-serve plans.
Swell includes customer groups and product price rules by group and quantity on every plan, per its pricing page. Accounts can be marked as business accounts with a VAT number, and accounts can hold a credit balance. Swell does not have native net terms, so an order paid by invoice needs a manual or app-based flow. Quote workflows and company hierarchies are things you model yourself with custom models and Swell Apps deployed with the Swell CLI.
If you need B2B Edition's features as a finished product, BigCommerce is the shorter path. If your wholesale model is mostly tiered and account-based pricing on top of a DTC store, Swell covers that without an enterprise contract.
Multi-Currency and Multi-Storefront
BigCommerce includes multi-currency on all self-serve plans, per its pricing page. Its Multi-Storefront feature runs several storefronts from one backend, each with its own domain, SSL certificate, default currency, branding, products and pricing. On the self-serve plans it is a paid add-on: $30, $50 and $100 a month on Core, Growth and Scale, for up to 3, 5 and 8 storefronts, per the same pricing page (checked Nov 2, 2026). This is a real advantage for brand portfolios and regional sites.
Swell supports two kinds of extra currency, per its currency docs. Display currencies convert from your base currency at a rate updated daily, then round using the currency's settings. Priced currencies carry prices you set directly. Per Swell's pricing page (checked Nov 2, 2026), multi-currency display is on every plan, while priced currencies, with checkout in that currency, are on Standard and Unlimited. Swell's APIs can serve several frontends from one store, but per-storefront domains, catalogs and pricing are something you design rather than a packaged feature.
Payments
BigCommerce sorts payment providers into two groups. Its embedded provider list (21 providers on Nov 2, 2026, including Stripe, PayPal Braintree, Adyen, Checkout.com, Worldpay, Klarna and Affirm) carries no BigCommerce fee. Any other provider is an Open Payment Provider and, since June 1, 2026, incurs a fee of 2.0% on Core, 1.0% on Growth and 0.6% on Scale, calculated on that provider's GMV. Performance contracts are exempt. BigCommerce states that offline orders count as Open Payment Provider volume, which matters for wholesale stores that record phone or invoice orders.
Swell's built-in card gateways are Stripe, Authorize.Net, Braintree, Saferpay and QuickPay. Alternative methods include PayPal, Amazon Pay, Klarna and Sezzle, and Apple Pay and Google Pay run through a supported card gateway. Swell's pricing page lists the plan price and the overage above each plan's sales ceiling, and no charge tied to which of these gateways you use. Authorize.Net is a useful example: it is built into Swell but is not on BigCommerce's embedded list as of Nov 2, 2026, so a BigCommerce merchant on Authorize.Net pays the Open Payment Provider fee.
On both platforms, approval to process payments is up to the payment provider, and processing fees are charged by the provider on top of anything the platform charges.
Cost Shape: One Worked Example
The store
A store selling $800K a year in gross online sales, spread evenly across the year, billed annually. To keep the comparison fair we leave out payment processing, because the same gateway (Stripe, for example) costs the same on both platforms. All BigCommerce figures come from its pricing page on Nov 2, 2026; all Swell figures from Swell's pricing page the same day.
BigCommerce
BigCommerce measures GMV as gross order value minus 10% on a trailing 12-month basis, so $800K in sales is $720K GMV. Core tops out at $30K and Growth at $100K, after which plans auto-upgrade, so this store is on Scale at $299 a month ($3,588 a year). Scale covers up to $33,333 a month of GMV and charges 0.9% above it. At $60,000 a month, the overage is 0.9% of $26,667, about $240 a month or $2,880 a year.
- With an embedded provider such as Stripe: $3,588 + $2,880 = $6,468 a year.
- With an open provider such as Authorize.Net: add 0.6% of $720K, or $4,320, for $10,788 a year.
Swell
Swell's plans include trailing-12-month sales up to a ceiling: Starter $29 a month up to $50K, Basic $79 up to $250K, Standard $299 up to $1M and Unlimited $2,250 up to $5M, billed yearly, with an overage of 2%, 1.5%, 1% and 0.4% on sales above the ceiling. Custom pricing applies above $10M a year. On Basic this store would pay $948 plus 1.5% of $550K, or $9,198. Standard covers it with no overage at $3,588 a year, so Standard is the right plan.
What the example shows
- At $200K a year: BigCommerce Scale at $3,588 (no overage at $180K GMV), or $4,668 with an open provider; Swell Basic at $948.
- At $800K a year: BigCommerce $6,468, or $10,788 with an open provider; Swell Standard $3,588.
- At $1.5M a year: BigCommerce Scale $3,588 plus about $8,550 in overage, or $12,138, rising to $20,238 with an open provider; Swell Standard $3,588 plus 1% of $500K, or $8,588.
Below about $110K a year in sales (Growth's $100K GMV cap), the two cost about the same, since both price their entry plans at $29 and $79 a month. The gap opens because Core and Growth caps are low and Scale's cap is measured monthly, while Swell's ceilings cover more sales per plan dollar. Because Scale's cap is stated per month, seasonal stores should confirm with BigCommerce how it is measured: a monthly cap can charge overage on peak months even if the annual average sits under it. At the top end, BigCommerce moves Scale accounts to Performance, a custom contract from $1,499 a month, once trailing GMV reaches $2M, and Swell's Unlimited plan becomes cheaper than Standard plus overage around $3.3M a year. Past those points, both are negotiated, and our BigCommerce enterprise pricing guide linked above is the better reference.
Apps change the totals too. A BigCommerce store that adds a subscription app pays that app's fee; a Swell store that needs a feature BigCommerce ships natively, such as multi-storefront or B2B quotes, pays in developer time instead.
Where BigCommerce Clearly Wins
- Multi-storefront as a product: separate domains, currencies, catalogs and pricing per storefront from one control panel.
- B2B Edition: company hierarchies, quotes, purchase orders, net terms and a buyer portal without custom development.
- App breadth: BigCommerce's app marketplace lists over 1,200 apps (checked Nov 2, 2026). Swell Apps is a smaller catalog.
- Sales channels: its Channel Manager is where merchants connect marketplaces such as Amazon, eBay and Walmart, and its Omni-Channel Availability article lists Google, Meta and TikTok ad channels through providers such as Feedonomics.
- Catalyst: a maintained, MIT-licensed Next.js storefront on a production GraphQL Storefront API.
- A mature hosted checkout with 21 embedded payment providers that carry no BigCommerce fee.
Reality Check: Fees, Quotas and Migration
Read the fee rules, not the headline price
Both platforms advertise $29, $79 and $299 entry plans, and both add percentage charges as you grow. BigCommerce's are the Scale overage, the auto-upgrade from Core and Growth, and the Open Payment Provider fee. Swell's is the overage above each plan's sales ceiling. BigCommerce's own June 2026 pricing post explains the plan renames and the new fee; read it alongside the pricing page before you model costs.
API and function quotas
Swell meters monthly API requests and function calls by plan. A busy headless storefront or a chatty ERP sync can exceed the Starter or Basic quota, which is billed in $5 blocks. BigCommerce limits GraphQL complexity per request. Load test either one before a big sale.
Migration in either direction
Products, customers and orders move between the two with scripts or migration tools. The hard parts are saved cards, which depend on your gateway's token migration process, subscriptions held in a third-party app, and any metafields or custom models that encode business logic. If you are leaving BigCommerce for reasons beyond these two platforms, our BigCommerce alternatives roundup covers the wider field.
Which Should You Pick
Choose BigCommerce if
- You run several brands or regions and want multi-storefront without building it.
- You need B2B Edition features such as quotes, net terms and company accounts as finished products.
- Marketplace and ad channel listings are a large part of revenue.
- Your team writes Next.js and wants Catalyst as a starting point.
- Your payment provider is on BigCommerce's embedded list and your sales stay within the plan caps you model.
Choose Swell if
- Your products need more than 600 variant combinations, conditional options or bundles that drive pricing.
- Subscriptions are central and you want them in the same data model and API as orders.
- You need records a standard commerce schema does not have and would rather model them than run a second database.
- Your wholesale needs are group and quantity pricing rather than a full B2B suite.
- You have developers who will own the storefront and integrations, and you want platform cost to follow Swell's sales ceilings rather than BigCommerce's GMV caps and open provider fee.
Whichever way you lean, spend a week modeling your two hardest products and your most complex order on both platforms before you commit. Swell offers a 14-day free trial, no credit card required, and BigCommerce publishes its own trial terms.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Swell cheaper than BigCommerce?
It depends on sales volume and payment provider. Below about $110K a year in sales the plans cost about the same. In our example at $800K a year, BigCommerce Scale costs $6,468 with an embedded provider and $10,788 with an open one, against $3,588 on Swell Standard, before processing fees on both.
Does BigCommerce charge transaction fees?
Since June 1, 2026, BigCommerce charges an Open Payment Provider fee of 2.0%, 1.0% or 0.6% on Core, Growth and Scale for orders through providers outside its embedded list, including offline orders. Scale also charges 0.9% on monthly GMV above $33,333.
How many variants can a product have on each platform?
BigCommerce allows 600 SKUs or variants per product. Swell lists unlimited variants on all plans.
Does BigCommerce have built-in subscriptions?
No. Subscriptions on BigCommerce come from third-party apps such as Ordergroove or Chargebee. Swell includes subscription plans, trials and separate billing and fulfillment schedules in its core platform on every plan.
Which is better for headless?
BigCommerce has Catalyst, an MIT-licensed Next.js storefront on a mature GraphQL Storefront API. Swell has a REST Backend API and the swell-js Frontend API, with GraphQL still in alpha, and it lets you expose custom models directly. Catalyst is faster to start; Swell gives more room in the data model.
Which is better for B2B?
For a full B2B suite with quotes, net terms and company accounts, BigCommerce B2B Edition. For group and quantity pricing on top of a DTC store, Swell covers it on every plan, though it has no native net terms.
Can I run multiple storefronts on Swell?
Swell's APIs can serve more than one frontend from one store, but per-storefront domains, catalogs and pricing are something you design. BigCommerce packages that as Multi-Storefront.
Build your store on Swell
Headless commerce with a full API on every plan, native subscriptions and custom data models. Start a store and see how it fits your build.